Published on Dec 11, 2024
Daily Editorials Analysis
Editorials/Opinions Analysis For UPSC 11 December 2024
Editorials/Opinions Analysis For UPSC 11 December 2024

Content:

  1. Two to tango
  1. Ends without means
  1. Deepening India’s steps as a key space-faring nation

Two To Tango


Background :

India-Bangladesh ties have deteriorated significantly, straining what was once considered a model bilateral relationship.

Relevance: GS 2 (International Relations)

Practice Question:Analyze the reasons for the strained relationship between India and Bangladesh.Suggest measures to strengthen the partnership .(250 Words)

Foreign Secretary’s Visit:

  • Indian Foreign Secretary Vikram Misri’s visit to Dhaka aimed at outreach with the interim government led by Professor Muhammad Yunus.
  • Emphasis on India’s willingness to collaborate closely with Bangladesh’s interim government.

Concerns from Both Sides:

India’s Concerns:

  • Attacks on minorities in Bangladesh.
  • Protests in Bangladesh targeting Indian missions and properties.

Bangladesh’s Concerns:

  • Alleged Indian interference in its domestic affairs.
  • Bangladesh’s dissatisfaction with Ms. Hasina’s prolonged stay in India and her perceived immunity from trial.

Tensions and Diplomatic Incidents:

  • Protests in India over Bangladesh’s arrest of a Hindu monk for sedition escalated bilateral tensions.
  • Retaliatory protests in Dhaka against Indian properties and missions worsened the situation.

Statements During the Visit:

  • Professor Yunus described bilateral relations as “solid” but acknowledged tensions created by Ms. Hasina’s remarks.

Key Issues Addressed:

  • Border management.
  • Trade and connectivity.
  • Water and energy cooperation.

Development collaboration.

  • Cultural and people-to-people ties.

India’s Strategy Moving Forward:

  • Need to balance concerns about attacks on minorities with efforts to restore Bangladesh’s democratic and inclusive processes.
  • Recognizing and adapting to the new political realities in Bangladesh after the violent ouster of India-friendly leadership.

 Regional Dynamics:

  • Recent political changes in Nepal, Sri Lanka, and the Maldives pose challenges for India’s regional diplomacy.
  • Stability in Bangladesh is crucial for India’s broader strategic interests in the region.

Ends Without Means


Background: The Draft UGC Regulations, 2024, aim to modernize India’s higher education with hybrid learning, skill-based education, and academic mobility.

Relevance: GS 2 (Governance)

Practice Question: Critically analyze proposed UGC reforms  benefits and the challenges in their  implementation.(150 Words)

Proposed Reforms:

  • Bi-annual admissions to UG and PG courses.
  • Flexibility for students to pursue any discipline after passing a relevant national qualifying exam.
  • Options for extending or accelerating courses and pursuing multiple degrees simultaneously.
  • Autonomy for institutions to set attendance requirements.

Alignment with NEP 2020:

  • Focus on hybrid learning and skill-based education.
  • Implementation of the National Credit Framework for academic flexibility.

Merits of the Reforms:

  • Removes rigidity in the higher education system.
  • Aims to meet global education standards.
  • Introduces groundbreaking flexibility like the academic bank of credits.

Challenges in Implementation:

Resource Constraints:

  • Insufficient faculty and underfunded institutions.
  • Lack of adequately trained or motivated teachers.

Regulatory Issues:

  • Weak governance in affiliated colleges, where most students study.
  • Resistance from traditional academic structures to reforms like credit banks.

Concurrent List Complications:

  • States’ initial compliance with reforms is often followed by backtracking.

Administrative Hurdles:

  • Inertia in academic bodies and procedures.

Budgetary Concerns:

  • The 2024 Budget reduced funding for higher education by 15% compared to last year’s revised estimates.
  • Lack of sufficient investment undermines the feasibility of implementing these ambitious reforms.

Deepening India’s Steps as a Key Space-Faring Nation


Context : ISRO has set Ambitious Goals for the Next Two Decades

Relevance : GS 3( Space )

Practice Question: Evaluate the role of the Next Generation Launch Vehicle (NGLV) in advancing India’s space programme. Highlight how private sector can be utilised in overcoming challenges .(250 Words )

  • Development of Next Generation Launch Vehicle (NGLV) for heavy lift and reusability.
  • Expansion of human-spaceflight capabilities:
    • Gaganyaan mission to send Indian crew to space.
  • Plans for a space station by the next decade.
  • Human missions to the moon.

ISRO’s Road Map:

  • Conduct multiple uncrewed lunar missions.
  • Master human-centric technologies for space travel.
  • Develop rockets capable of carrying heavy payloads efficiently and cost-effectively.

 NGLV: A Game-Changer:

  • Triples the payload capacity of LVM3.
  • Partially reusable, offering significant cost savings.

Advantages:

  • Heavy lift rockets reduce weight constraints for space missions.
  • Reusability ensures competitiveness and cost efficiency.
  • Challenges: Reduced payload capacity due to fuel requirements for reusability.

Current Gaps in Heavy Lift Capability:

  • India is already facing the need for heavy lift rockets
  • Next uncrewed lunar mission requires two LVM3s to assemble modules in space.
  • GSAT-N2 satellite (4,700 kg) launched on SpaceX Falcon 9 due to LVM3’s 4,000 kg limit.
  • SpaceX’s Falcon 9 and Starship far exceed India’s payload capacities.

Private Sector Role:

Leverage Indian Industry:

  • Contracts to private players for reusable heavy-lift rocket development.
  • Encourage foreign collaborations for expertise and technology transfer.

Funding Mechanism:

  • Milestone-based funding to ensure accountability and reduce costs.

Potential Outcomes:

  • Redundancy and higher launch frequency with multiple NGLV-like rockets.
  • Innovation and technical capacity building in the private sector.

Strategic Autonomy and Resilient Space Ecosystem:

  • Space ambitions require a robust supply of launch services.
  • Foster a specialised industrial base to support India’s growing needs in space transportation.