Editorials/Opinions Analysis For UPSC 03 June 2025
Cotent : Misinformation a bigger threat than COVID-19 uptick Monsoon woes Strengthening the U.S.-India subsea cable agenda Misinformation a bigger threat than COVID-19 uptick Current COVID-19 Situation Uptick in cases in India since mid-May 2025, rising from a few to a few hundred daily. Wastewater surveillance confirms increased viral load in some Indian cities. Similar trends in Singapore, Hong Kong, Thailand, and South Korea. Relevance : GS 2(Health , Governance) Practice Question : “Misinformation is a bigger threat than the current COVID-19 uptick.” Discuss in the context of India’s public health governance.(250 Words) Variant Context The dominant variant: JN.1 (Pirola) — an Omicron sub-variant, not new. First detected in August 2023 in Luxembourg; circulating in India since late 2023. No significant clinical difference from parent Omicron variant. Sub-lineages like LF.7 and NB.1.8 also detected — no added severity. Reasons for Case Uptick Persistence of virus: SARS-CoV-2 likely to become endemic and seasonal, similar to flu. Mutation-prone nature: RNA viruses mutate frequently, causing new sub-lineages. Increased testing and surveillance: Boost in detection due to precautionary response to regional trends. Epidemiological Trends Possible seasonal pattern emerging: Every 8–10 months in India (waves in Jan 2022, early 2023, Dec 2023-Jan 2024, July-Aug 2024, May 2025). Hybrid immunity (natural + vaccine) doesn’t prevent infection, but reduces severity. No surge in hospitalizations or severe cases observed. Numbers in Perspective Daily COVID-19 cases (200–300) = 1 case per 45–70 lakh population. Daily burden of other diseases: TB: ~8,000 new cases/day; ~900 deaths/day. Influenza virus: ~390 deaths/day. RSV disease: ~310 deaths/day. Air pollution-related diseases: much higher. COVID-19’s current impact is minor compared to other ongoing health challenges. Misleading Metrics ‘Active case’ counts are outdated and misleading — used during the initial pandemic when immunity was low. With widespread hybrid immunity, most individuals become non-infectious within a day or two. On Vaccination No need for additional COVID-19 vaccine doses for the general population. Memory cells in the immune system provide long-term protection from severe disease. Flu and age-appropriate vaccines are more beneficial, especially for high-risk individuals. Key Concerns Infodemic (misinformation) is a bigger threat than the current uptick in infections. Overreaction could strain health systems, cause panic, and lead to response fatigue. Way Forward Avoid panic; adopt a rational, epidemiological, and proportionate response. COVID-19 should now be treated like any mild respiratory illness unless new evidence suggests otherwise. Government and citizens should: Monitor trends. Avoid rumour-mongering. Maintain public trust by avoiding false alarms. Monsoon woes Onset & Its Impact The southwest monsoon has begun forcefully, entering via Kerala (Arabian Sea branch) and Andaman-Nicobar/Northeast (Bay of Bengal branch). The Bay of Bengal branch often brings early and intense rains to northeastern States, frequently triggering floods and landslides. Relevance : GS 1(Geography ) , GS 3(Disaster Management) Practice Question : “Monsoon woes in Northeast India demand region-specific disaster management and long-term mitigation strategies.” Discuss.(250 Words) Current Situation in Northeast India (As of May-End & Early June) Assam: 10 major rivers are above danger levels. Over 3 lakh people affected across 19 districts. Tripura: Experienced heavy to very heavy rainfall; more downpours expected. Sikkim: Landslides in North Sikkim trapped ~1,500 tourists. A bus fell into Teesta River; fatalities and missing passengers reported. Overall toll (as of May 31): At least 52 deaths due to floods, landslides, flash floods, lightning. Structural & Climatic Concerns Despite IMD’s projection of below-normal monsoon for the northeast, the region’s base rainfall is inherently high → makes even “normal” rains damaging. Northeast receives two monsoons: June–September (Southwest) October–December (Retreating/Northeast monsoon) This makes it a year-round vulnerable region. Chronic Issues Inadequate infrastructure due to: Challenging terrain. Neglected investment & planning. Disasters recur annually, yet no significant long-term mitigation framework is in place. Need for Long-term Planning Call for a sustainable, region-specific flood and landslide mitigation strategy. Requires: Centre–State collaboration. Comprehensive vulnerability mapping. Resilient infrastructure development. Pre-disaster planning and early warning systems. Strengthening the U.S.-India subsea cable agenda Strategic Context U.S.-India ties are expanding across trade and technology, especially under the TRUST framework (successor to iCET). Subsea cables, vital for 95%+ of global Internet traffic, are emerging as a critical digital infrastructure priority. China’s Digital Silk Road expansion in the Indo-Pacific underscores the urgency of trusted alternatives. Relevance : GS 2(International Relations) , GS 3(Technology) Practice Question : “Examine the strategic significance of subsea cables in the U.S.-India partnership and discuss how both countries can strengthen cooperation to enhance digital resilience in the Indo-Pacific.” (250 Words) Why Subsea Cables Matter Subsea cables connect continents, enable cloud services, and support critical infrastructure. They are essential for: Digital economy functioning. National security. Regional strategic influence. India’s Current Landscape India has 17 subsea cables (vs Singapore’s 26) — underutilized potential. Geographical advantages: 11,098 km coastline. Central location in Indo-Pacific. Rising data demand and digital economy. Yet, cable landing stations are overly concentrated in Mumbai (15/17 landings within a 6-km stretch). High risk of disruption due to natural disasters or sabotage. Strategic & Economic Opportunity India is well-placed to become a global subsea cable transit hub: Near major maritime chokepoints (Hormuz, Malacca, Bab-el-Mandeb). Central to Africa-Asia and Europe-Asia cable routes. Positioned to serve dynamic emerging economies (e.g., Indonesia, Africa). Domestic bandwidth demand growing at 38% CAGR (2021–2028). Challenges and Barriers Regulatory complexity: Over 50 approvals needed from multiple ministries for undersea cable projects. Dependency on foreign-flagged repair ships: Ships based in Singapore/Dubai take 3–5 months to respond to faults. Cumbersome clearance processes → long downtimes and commercial loss. Recommended Steps India Must: Simplify licensing and regulatory clearance for cable projects. Develop a domestic repair ecosystem: Indian-flagged repair ships. Dedicated depot infrastructure. Diversify cable landing sites to build network redundancy. U.S. Must: Provide concessional financing and technical assistance. Encourage U.S. firms to anchor undersea cable projects (e.g., Meta’s 50,000-km initiative). Collaborate under the TRUST framework to promote secure and diversified subsea routes. Conclusion Subsea cable collaboration will: Boost digital resilience of the Indo-Pacific. Counter China’s influence in the region. Deepen strategic and commercial ties between India and the U.S. It must be treated as a frontline strategic priority under the evolving bilateral and Quad partnerships